STRANGEST COINCIDENCE EVER – OR HOAX?

STRANGEST COINCIDENCE EVER – OR HOAX?
The case of the Polish Rxb2


Black to play
‘Ortueta – Sanz’
Madrid 1933

ONE OF THE MOST FAMOUS and beautiful combinations that ever occurred over the board is the one in the diagram on the left. Petrosyan once said that when he first saw it at age 10, it thrilled him so much that it was a major factor in binding him to chess forever. Hugh Alexander wrote: ‘I always have trouble believing that this endgame really occurred in a game, and not during a post-mortem.’ And when the great endgame composer Henri Rinck was asked by Tartakower if this could not be turned into something really beautiful, he said that nothing needed to be added, nothing needed to be cut.
The key move of the combination (if you know there is one) may be obvious: 1…Rxb2!! Sanz, a one-time champion of Spain (1943), and 25 years old at the time, found the move that made him immortal after some forty-five minutes of calculating. 2.Nxb2 c3 3.Rxb6 (or 3.Nd3 c4+ 4.Rxb6 cxd3 etc.) If now 3…axb6 4.Nd3, but: 3…c4! This move, and the next, are not obvious at

Position after 4.Rb4

all. Rook and Knight down, Black finds time for a quiet move to cover d3. 4.Rb4 The only move. (See diagram on the right.)
4…a5! The crux of the combination and, as Sanz later said, the most difficult move to find. Now Black cannot be stopped from queening. There are two ways in which White can play for a draw:
a) 5.Nxc4 c2 This happened in the game. Some sources say White resigned here, others that he resigned after a few more moves. There might follow: 6.Rb3 cl=Q+ 7.Kf2 Qxc4 etc., or:
b) 5.Rxc4 cxb2 followed by promotion with, in both cases, a Q vs. R endgame that Black can win without too much trouble.
But these endgames are not relevant because, as we shall see below, the ‘Ortueta-Sanz’ position as I gave it in the first diagram (which is the way it is almost always given) is a stylised version, probably invented to make sure Rxb2 is the only way to win.

CategoriesUncategorised

Leave a Reply