Notes by team captain Cillian Howlett.
What a day in Kildare – five hard earned draws in one of our tightest matches ever! Great player determination on a day for which the result could have gone either way by a large margin. Well the final result was fair for both teams who pulled out all the stops.
Michael Johnston (Board 1 – White) was the star of the match who managed to hold off a 1560 rated player despite a positional error in the opening. Michael fought his way back into the game and the battle looked quite equal by the late middle game – an endgame was looking quite likely and an endgame it was – each army with just its King, one Bishop and a few pawns remaining. Black had a pawn advantage in numbers, but with the opposing Bishops on opposite colours, the actual position was far less clear. White did have to be accurate in order to secure a draw but Michael found the exact moves and forced the draw. A pat on the back by a delighted Captain followed – well done Magic Mike!!!
Paul McDonnell (Board 2 – Black) had the longest game of the match which nearly went the distance. Paul started off with pressure against the White fortress, but White managed to shut down the centre and just as Black was walking his King to the centre to make way for a plan B Kingside Rook attack, the Kingside was also shut down and White started to open the Queenside! With Black’s King getting a bit of air, Paul was now in trouble and in fact, there was a Queen winning combination against the Black King that White overlooked. However, Black got to breath again and started to improve his position by generating Queen and Rook activity on the Queenside albeit a pawn down. Eventually, with the time on both clocks close to expiring, Paul overlooked a forced mate sequence upon a draw offer. The captain, seizing the opportunity to avoid team defeat, was also oblivious and advised acceptance. So it was a personal draw for a team draw! Good Fightback Paul!
Frank Pentony (Board 3 – White) had a good solid opening which appeared to lend White a dominant middle game position. The material balance appeared even for much of the game. Black having castled long gave Frank plenty of reason to mount a Queenside attack which appeared to put Black under constant pressure. Black defended and White eventually went an exchange down – it’s not clear if this was an exchange sacrifice in order to maintain the momentum of White’s attack. However, with Black hanging on and White continuing to press, the battle became bogged down and eventually Frank was offered a draw which he accepted upon the Captain’s advice. Another hard earned result!
Adam Churchill (Board 4 – Black) finally got to make his seasonal debut in the BEA league and did so in solid fashion. With the Black pieces, he put his opponent under considerable pressure in what turned out the be the second longest game of the match. Eventually, it appeared that Black had won a piece for a pawn which he may have substituted for a two pawn advantage. Eventually, there was just over twenty minutes left on both clocks amid a tricky position. Even with two extra pawns, it was not clear how Adam would convert his advantage prior to the fall of a flag. There seemed to be a lot of chess remaining to be played out – well the time was too tight for such and a draw was agreed. Very good result Adam!
Cillian Howlett (Board 5 – White) got into some form of the Exchange Slav after Black played the light square Bishop to g4 attacking the White f3 Knight. In the shortest game of the match, White decided to build a solid Kingside fortress with connected Knights and exchanged the c pawn to simplify the centre. Cillian also fianchettoed the Queens Bishop to pressurise the centre which in turn was to allow a Knight outpost on e5 supported by a replacement Knight on f3 – this looked like a good plan. Black however was having none of it and played an awkward Knight to e4 to ruin White’s aspirations. Black also played the dark square Bishop to d6 (eying White’s h2) and marched the h pawn instead of castling – the Rook on h8 was now becoming very active. Eventually, Black’s Queen joined in and provoked Cillian’s g3. When the Queen moved from the pawn attack, the Black h pawn could march and did. In time, White played a poor move that allowed Black to air out White’s King with a weakening pawn exchange on g3 followed by a Bishop sacrifice. Now, the White King had the Black Queen and Rook to deal with amid many a possibility for substantial material gain and checkmate on the cards. White had to be extremely accurate to save the game. Well Cillian found the right moves and saved the game. Good Result!
To sum up the match in general – we got a very hard earned result in what was an extremely tight match – the team as a whole performed very strongly. There was sheer determination on the faces of both teams to win and neither deserved to lose on the day. A win for Drogheda would have been nice, but at the same we didn’t lose and most importantly, we did our best and that’s the main thing in chess! This result moves the team to 3rd in the table temporarily, with a 50% score.
Next up is Dublin (home) at the end of February, so the team can enjoy a well earned rest.

