How not to play a pawn ending…….Alan!!

Here is an instructive game – and ending in particular – from last week’s Heidenfeld action as noted by Ciarán Ruane, St Benildus, on his match with our own Alan Dee. Worth reading and thanks to our friends at St Benildus for this from their website 🙂

Ciarán Ruane (1559) v Alan Dee (1570); Heidenfeld Trophy; 12 January 2013

1.e4 c5 2.Nf3 d6 3.d4 cxd4 4.Nxd4 Nf6 5.Nc3 a6 6.Bg5 e6 7.f4 Be7 8.Qf3 e5
8…Qc7 is the theory move as played in probably millions of games. I won’t waste anyone’s time with my thoughts on the position!

9.Nf5 Bxf5
Forced. 9…Bf8 10.fxe5 dxe5 11.Nd5 is the computer’s next best line!

10.exf5 Nc6 11.0-0-0 Qa5 12.Bxf6 Bxf6 13.Ne4 0-0 14.Bc4
The computer prefers 14.Nxf6+ gxf6 15.Kb1 but this is still good. I wanted to put a bit more pressure on the kingside and cover a2 at the same time.

14…Nd4 15.Qg4
15.Nxf6+ is apparently better for White after 15…gxf6 16.Qg4+ Kh8 17.Qh4 though the computer’s preferred line is 17…Qa4 18.Bd3 Rac8 19.Qxf6+ Kg8 20.Kb1 Rxc2 21.Bxc2 Qxc2+ 22.Ka1 which is pretty wild.

15…Qd8 16.c3 Rc8
Any knight move allows Rxd6 which is crushing.

17.Bd5 exf4 18.Kb1 Nb5 19.Qxf4
19.g3 is interesting too and might be better.

19…Nxc3+? (D)

Ruane v Dee 1

I hadn’t seen this coming at all and assumed my opponent had seen some crushing win for me and played this out of desperation but from the Drogheda site, it seems that he might have missed that the knight on e4 was covering c3 and was looking at 20.bxc3 Qb6+ 21.Kc2 Rxc3+ 22.Kd2 Be5 23.Qg5 h6 when I have to give up my queen to stop the mate on e3.

20.Nxc3
Kevin suggested 20.bxc3 Bxc3 21.f6 which looks strong. The computer prefers 21.Nxd6, but there’s no need for another pawn I don’t think.

20…Bxc3 21.bxc3 Rxc3 22.Qd4
Again 22.f6 is probably better.

22…Qa5 23.Rc1?
A stupid blunder (as usual 23.f6 is the move).

23…Qb5+ 24.Bb3
I’d intended 24.Ka1 but of course 24…Rd3 wins the bishop.

24…Qxf5+ 25.Ka1 Rc5
25…Rd3 is probably better as this drops the d-pawn.

26.Qxd6 Rfc8
This lets White force a queen swap. 26…Rxc1+ allows Black keep some pressure on the white king.

27.Rxc5 Qxc5 (D) 28.Qxc5

Ruane v Dee 2

The computer points out 28.Bxf7+! winning a pawn because 28…Kxf7 allows 29.Rf1+ Kg8 30.Rf8+ winning the queen but I never looked past swapping the queens immediately.

28…Rxc5 29.Rd1 Kf8 30.Rd7 Rc1+ 31.Kb2 Rf1 32.Bd5
With the bishop covering the pawns this should be straightforward from here.

32…b5
32…Rd1 threatening 33.Ke8 doesn’t work as 33.Rxf7+ Ke8 34.Rf5 keeps everything safe.

33.Kc3 a5 34.Rxf7+???
Awful, just awful. Not just that I miscalculated the pawn endgame but there was no need to take the chance on it at all. 34.Kd4 is obviously much better. Threats of 35.Kc5 and 35.Rxf7+ (the extra tempo makes all the difference!) are too strong. For example 34…a4 (34…f6 allows 35.Rf7+ Ke8 36.Rxg7) 35.Rxf7+ Rxf7 36.Bxf7 Kxf7 37.Kc5 Ke6 38.Kxb5 or 34…Rd1+ 35.Kc5 Rf1 36.Kxb5 Rf5 37.Kc5 are trivial wins.

34…Rxf7 35.Bxf7 Kxf7 36.Kd4 Ke6 37.Kc5 b4 (D)

Ruane v Dee 3

This was the move that I’d missed. After anything else, I could pick up the two queenside pawns and have an easy win.

38.Kb5 Kd5 39.Kxa5 Kc4 40.Ka4 h6 41.h3 (D)

Ruane v Dee 4

This position is drawn but it’s much more subtle than I realised at the time.

41…g5??
Surprisingly, this loses.

41…h5 draws (41…Kc3 or 41…Kc5 end up the same as long as Black pushes his pawns in the same order). The point is to have the two pawns separated to cost White more time in taking them after Black plays b3, White can’t do anything useful in the meantime.

For example, 42.h4 Kc3 (as we’ll see, 41…Kc5 will end up in the same position) 43.Kb5 b3 44.axb3 Kxb3 45.Kc5 Kc3 46.Kd5 Kd3 47.Ke5 Ke3 48.Kf5 Kf2

Ruane v Dee 5

49.Kg5 Kxg2 50.Kxh5 Kg3 51.Kg5 g6=

42.g3 is similar 42…Kc3 43.Kb5 b3 44.axb3 Kxb3 45.Kc5 Kc3 46.Kd5 Kd3 47.Ke5 Ke3 48.Kf5 Kf3 49.Kg5 Kxg3 50.Kxh5 Kxh3=

41…g6 doesn’t work as it allows White to play 42.h4 and achieve the separated pawns set-up. 42…Kc5 (42…g5 is no good either as after 43.hxg5 hxg5 44.g4, White gets to Black’s pawn first after the eventual b3.) 43.Ka5 Kc4 44.Kb6 b3 (Running off to the kingside is far too slow as we’ll see in the game so this is the only important line.) 45.axb3+ Kxb3 46.Kc5 Kc3 47.Kd5 Kd3 48.Ke5 Ke3 49.Kf6 Kf4 (D)

Ruane v Dee 6

50.Kxg6 Kg4 51.h5

42.g4!!
The only winning move (not that I knew that at the time)

42…Kc3
I knew I was winning after this but 42…Kc5 actually transposes to the same position after 43.Ka5 Kc4 44.Kb6 Kc3 45.Kb5.
I’d only looked at 42…Kc5 43.Kb3 when 43…Kb5 44.Kc2 (44.Kb2 actually draws too in a neat way. 44…Ka4 45.Kc1 Ka3 46.Kb1 b3 47.axb3 Kxb3 48.Kc1 Kc3 49.Kd1 Kd3 50.Ke1 Ke3 51.Kf1 Kf3 52.h4 gxh4 leaves Black with only rook pawns and 52…Kxg4 53.hxg5 hxg5 54.Kg2 is also drawn.) 44…Ka4 45.Kb2 is a draw.

43.Kb5 b3
Running straight to the kingside with 43…Kd3 is no good as 44.Kxb4 Ke3 45.Kc4 Kf3 46.Kd4 Kg3 47.Ke4 Kxh3 48.Kf5 is pretty much the same as the game and 43…Kb2 44.Kxb4 Kxa2 leaves Black several tempi short.

44.axb3 Kd3
44…Kxb3 is still losing. White gets to Black’s pawns one move earlier. 45.Kc5 Kc3 46.Kd5 Kd3 47.Ke5 Ke3 48.Kf6 Kf3

Ruane v Dee 7

49.Kg6 Kg3 50.Kxh6 Kxh3 51.Kxg5

45.Kc5 Ke3 46.b4 Kf3 47.Kd5
47.b5 Kg3 48.b6 Kxh3 49.b7 Kxg4 50.b8Q mates faster but bringing the king over is much simpler.

47…Kg3 48.Ke5 Kxh3 49.Kf5 h5 50.gxh5 1-0

CategoriesUncategorised

Leave a Reply